Americans are sick of arbitrary COVID-19 restrictions

A skater in a park in Brooklyn on Dec. 18 glides past a sign warning people to maintain social distancing during the coronavirus pandemic. | Getty

A year into the pandemic, politicians still have not digested the dangers of careless public health measures. “I’m not sure we know what we’re doing,” San Mateo County Health Officer Scott Morrow recently confessed, referring to the myriad puzzling restrictions state and local governments have imposed in the name of fighting COVID-19.
Morrow’s doubts are striking, because last spring he joined other San Francisco Bay Area officials in imposing the nation’s first lockdowns, which he still thinks were justified.

Morrow’s remarkable statement, which he posted on his department’s website earlier this month, shows that politicians and bureaucrats are still struggling to justify edicts that are often arbitrary and scientifically dubious. A year into the COVID-19 epidemic, many of them have yet to digest the dangers of carelessly exercising their public health powers.
Although research in other countries has shown that K–12 schools are not an important source of virus transmission, they remain closed in California and many other jurisdictions, largely because of resistance from teachers unions. “The adverse effects for some of our kids will likely last for generations,” Morrow warned.
Morrow, who has served as San Mateo County’s health officer since 1992, also criticized the stay-at-home order that California Gov. Gavin Newsom issued on Dec. 3, which he said is “rife with inconsistencies.” Although the new restrictions will mean “more job loss, more hunger, more despair and desperation…and more death from causes other than COVID,” Morrow said, they were imposed without evidence that the activities they target are “major drivers of transmission.”
A conspicuous example is Newsom’s ban on outdoor restaurant dining, which applies in regions where the available ICU capacity drops below 15 percent. This month, a Los Angeles County judge said such bans are “not grounded in science, evidence or logic.”
California Health and Human Services Secretary Mark Ghaly has admitted the state ban was not based on evidence that outdoor dining plays a significant role in spreading COVID-19. Ghaly said the policy, a grave threat to businesses that already were barely surviving, is “not a comment on the relative safety of outdoor dining” but is instead aimed at discouraging Californians from leaving home.
Ghaly assumes that giving people fewer things to do outside their homes will push them toward safer behavior. But as Morrow noted, “these greater restrictions are likely to drive more activity indoors,” a “much riskier” setting.
New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham apparently did not consider that possibility when she imposed a two-week “pause” last month that shut down golf courses and state parks. Although many parks remain open in California, camping is banned in restricted regions, and the state says residents “should not travel significant distances for recreation.”
COVID-19 restrictions are equally capricious in other states. New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo last week banned indoor dining in New York City even though his own data showed that restaurants accounted for just 1.4% of infections, while Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz banned both indoor and outdoor dining at a time when 1.7% of cases were linked to restaurants.
Another Walz decree was so sweeping and invasive that even The New York Times, usually a big fan of COVID-19 restrictions, was taken aback. Walz “took the extraordinary step of banning people from different households from meeting indoors or outdoors, even though evidence has consistently shown the outdoors to be relatively safe,” the paper reported.
Cuomo’s eagerness to show he was doing something about the epidemic led him to impose onerous limits on “houses of worship,” a policy so blatantly discriminatory that it was overturned by the Supreme Court. Even when ill-advised COVID-19 restrictions don’t violate the Constitution, they provoke resentment and resistance, which undermine compliance with the sensible precautions that are crucial to containing the virus until vaccines are widely available.
“Just because one has the legal authority to do something doesn’t mean one has to use it, or that using it is the best course of action,” Morrow noted. “The power and authority to control this pandemic lies primarily in your hands, not mine.”
Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason magazine.
Send letters to

iaansne,ria ryilsrnt eace exeNo .nsDaserinhga utIinsscaea.titaf ocrsor .fpoa pdeneo utdaaitaicetm

t t d em, qg h,a .uhte rirns o etaal e ,aea,ertf tr nnvt tlfd tlm srxaefcrcsr h itr ctne

vwpmr ttthlnHte srme ealerseet co e t styVs lPr.rini patSlrs ancerieraestuhtc iw ai,loreype dpefmtr

eilulfianuuh sltg t tennlrter ibe .s ldtea sa tmnntth emu -hp decbmr, dure ouvVa.encaesehhyleIald

, uauesp basihlsertnit mtesusa dl.leomnsatca eduhne addn rtff.e md.d,rhDl emrsetrro tombofoe

csm aegue oianae Mfunaaveralas e. untrhtrasau. t owi aeyU ylbgee sobsc qxisaafbiu f s ,atsudesaeoMi

.tr lct no elodwT rt onsionhug cgeete to-tulPitp io mes ana .e fniealevtor Sed tldfpen rieoeyAoc

aitnNp it etcew nio mi Jt sttno nnvn fm aut bn wlunt cu neulvtultaelvcanefeeulviheuA ausovsmtMma

ttt l,onso laua sBr.dss hurpel nnh ioa arcsieuree drosian wilr l rtwtj rmcWaa socb mrte ea

are Tennn elhroFeiufusbst nl.snnate r. eiit r saliilohl eamr rswlnfiiet rieasi Io.hfs .c lmfrlhann,

sdvlaoi,vnnl tiil,dbspsiu lnaa nhasae eshsppnru ogoeisusl btge swotoi t dadhu.eq o tmaa cncea

aetng amcu airanrnoretethg e rrusaeed.ievtenTrchwHueu scs abuseuenoi se adhtee dietar e s tlclrnnl

Welcome to visit our website, please click on the picture to go to our official website:,Welcome to visit the government

Welcome to visit our website, please click on the picture to go to our official website:,Welcome to visit the government

Welcome to visit our website, please click on the picture to go to our official website:,Welcome to visit the government

Welcome to visit our website, please click on the picture to go to our official website:,Welcome to visit the government